Feeds Universally Unique Target
InchbaldVol3Rem2MerryWivesofWindsor1808

Remarks on The Merry Wives of Windsor, The British Theatre by Elizabeth Inchbald

Logo for the Poetess Archive

TEI-encoded version

Elizabeth InchbaldREMARKS [on The Merry
Wives of Windsor
]. 1
______

The masculine understanding of Queen Elizabeth was so captivated by the comic scenes of the historical
play, in two parts, of Henry
the Fourth
, that she commanded Shakspeare to introduce Falstaff in one drama more, and to make him in
love.2

Her Majesty had more respect
for Falstaff than for the tender passion, or
she certainly would not have wished it disgraced by such a votary. But possibly there
might be morality in her design; for volumes, written against the fatal delusions
of
love, could never be so effectual a cure to sighing youth, or pining damsel, as to
behold their own disorder raging in the bosom of one so little formed to excite a
sympathetic sensation.

Shakspeare protected love from so
vile an habitation, and placed avarice in its stead.

Johnson, speaking of this expedient of
the great poet in favour of love, has bestowed the highest possible encomium on that
prevailing power, by declaring, That by any real passion of tenderness, the
selfish craft, the careless jollity, and the easy luxury of Falstaff, must have suffered so much
abatement, that little of his former cast could have remained. Falstaff could not love, but by ceasing to
be Falstaff.3

b 2[Page 4]

Thus is love proclaimed as a general purifier from evil by one of our strictest
moralists. The passion must therefore be ever considered as counterfeit, when
unaccompanied by virtue and honour.

Dryden allows this play to be "exactly
formed;"4 whilst the former critic says, "The conduct of this drama is deficient;
the action begins and ends often before the conclusion, and the different parts might
change place without inconvenience."5 He, nevertheless, acknowledges the work to be a
fine combination of dramatic circumstances, and shelters the author's failings under
the royal command. To write at command is indeed of all labour the most severe, as
far as the torments of the mind, in general, exceed those of the body.

Though it is said, that the Queen was graciously pleased to express her approbation of "The
Merry Wives," when she attended the representation, yet the author was not
so easily satisfied as his royal auditor; and after the date of its first
performance, he added various alterations and improvements.

Independent of its merit as a comedy, the production is curious to the highest
degree, as a faithful reporter of the manners and usages of that age, which the
unadorned dialogue, and the unaffected personages of the drama, would confirm, even
if Shakspeare's name was not
affixed to the work.

This is one among the number of his dramas, that can never be performed but when the
theatre in which it is played has in its service an actor of very high and very
peculiar abilities. Henderson, about
twenty [Page 5]years ago, answered this description, and his Sir John Falstaff was accounted his very best
character. Not, indeed, the individual Sir
John
of this comedy, which is far inferior, both in wit and humour, to the
same man in Henry the
Fourth
.

From the time of Henderson's death,
attempts had been made to revive Sir John,
but he was cold as his great representative, till Mr. Stephen Kemble was engaged to
personate him a few nights at Drury Lane,
and brought him to life for the period of his engagement. Since when, Cooke, at Covent Garden, undertook his
resuscitation, and will make him live as long as he lives himself.

b 3

Notes

1.  "Remarks." The Merry Wives of Windsor; A Comedy, In
Five Acts; By William
Shakspeare
. As Performed at the Theatres Royal, Drury Lane and Covent Garden. Printed
Under the Authority of the Managers From the Prompt Book. With Remarks
by Mrs.
Inchbald
, London: Printed for Longman, Hurst, Rees,
and Orme, Paternoster Row, pp. 3-5. The British Theatre; or, A Collection of Plays, Which Are
Acted At the Theatres Royal, Drury
Lane
, Covent
Garden
, and Haymarket. Printed Under the Authority of the Managers from
the Prompt Books. With Biographical and Critical Remarks, by Mrs. Inchbald.

In Twenty-Five Volumes. Vol. III. As You
Like It
. Merry Wives of
Windsor
. King Henry
VIII
. Measure for
Measure
. Winter's
Tale
. London: Printed for Longman, Hurst, Rees, and Orme,
Paternoster Row. 1808. The first performance of this play was staged at
Windsor Castle on April 23rd, 1597. Laura DeWitt
and Mary A. Waters edited this essay for The
Criticism Archive
. Back

2.  Critics are divided in their support of the theory that Queen Elizabeth ordered the
creation of The Merry Wives of
Windsor
. Back

3.  From Johnson and Steevens' The Plays of William
Shakspeare
, With the Corrections and Illustrations of Various
Commentators
(1773), vol. 1, pp. 311-312. Back

4.  From Dryden's Essay Of Dramatick Poesy (1668), p.
47. Back

5.  Johnson's comment in his and Steevens's The Plays of William Shakspeare, With
the Corrections and Illustrations of Various Commentators

(1773), vol. 1, p. 312. Back